DreamWorks Animation has come a really long way. They have made some of the most beloved animated films of all time. Most notably, the Shrek series. Sure, DreamWorks had popular titles like The Prince of Egypt, Chicken Run and even El Dorado as a start, but it is Shrek that has become the most iconic above all the others. I think DreamWorks credits Shrek for there success. A question has come up since the dawn of time, Shrek or Shrek 2? When the second Shrek film came out, it was rare to find people that enjoyed it more than the first one. Those who did were definitely in the minority. Times have changed, when asked that same question again a surprising majority favor the sequel over it’s predecessor. To answer that question to the best of my ability, I will be comparing the two films using a criteria of different factors.
- Soundtrack
One of the main reasons why these two movies are so popular is because of the sound tracks. I mean who can forget the opening to Shrek with All Star by Smash Mouth playing in the background. It’s one of the most iconic moments in cinematic history. I’m exaggerating of course, but honestly it’s really good. There is also the sequence where Shrek defeats all of the guards when he arrives at Duloc. The song Bad Reputation by Joan Jett is used during this scene which helps to provide for the comedic moments, but overall for how badass it is. There are many more songs used in this film, but my favorite one has to be Hallelujah. The use of this song and the montage scenes that go along with it evoke a sense of anguish.
In the case of Shrek 2, most of it’s musical moments are performed by Jennifer Saunders who plays the Fairy Godmother. With her presence and surprisingly good vocals, she is able to make these songs unforgettable. I am of course referring to when she sang the fairy godmother song to Fiona and when she sings Holding Out for a Hero at Fiona and Prince Charming’s wedding. When Shrek and the gang come to far far away land, Funky Town is blared. This song is able to provide for this Hollywood-esque environment, also letting us know that we aren’t in the swamp anymore. Changes by David Bowie is also played in the film during an integral part of the story.
In conclusion, I believe Shrek takes the cake for the better soundtrack. The musical accompaniment of the scenes were executed better than Shrek 2. I am not saying that the songs were better, but that the execution of them was. For me, the songs from the first film were more memorable.
2. Plot
The IMDB plot summary for Shrek is as follows “A mean lord exiles fairytale creatures to the swamp of a grumpy ogre, who must go on a quest and rescue a princess for the lord in order to get his land back.” This is a very simple and straightforward description of the story. I think that the majority of Shrek is essentially a road trip movie. Which isn’t a bad thing. The main characters of Shrek, Donkey, and Lord Farquaad are introduced and it isn’t long before Shrek and Donkey make there journey to find Princess Fiona. As the film progresses, we watch as our characters interact and connect onscreen. It than leads to drama that leaves Fiona fleeing from Shrek in the hopes of marrying Lord Farquaad. Through some dialogue between Donkey and Shrek, they both decide to go back to the castle, to win back Fiona. All in all, it’s a plot that’s easy to follow and makes for entertaining and funny moments. It has comedy, adventure, romance, and other ingredients to make for an engaging watch.
Shrek 2 takes a slightly different path. This is another plot summary, courtesy of IMDB. “Shrek and Fiona travel to the Kingdom of Far Far Away, where Fiona’s parents are King and Queen, to celebrate their marriage. When they arrive, they find they are not as welcome as they thought they would be.” Our protagonist and friends, who we know and love, have been introduced and now we explore them even further. We get to learn about Fiona’s heritage, upbringing, and parents. This creates for some effective tension between Shrek and Fiona’s father. As a result, we see Shrek and Fiona argue as a married couple for the first time. New characters are presented like Prince Charming, Fairy Godmother, and last but certainly not least, Puss in Boots. With the addition of these new players, comes more exciting drama that is brought to the screen. Some of which make us look at our old characters differently. Shrek is turned into a man, Donkey a horse. These drastic changes help pull the audience in, simultaneously bringing in more hilarious moments.
Shrek takes a simple plot and still manages to make it insanely entertaining. However, Shrek 2 wins. Shrek 2‘s plot allows us to explore the many relationships in this franchise, much deeper. The drama is far more compelling this time around.
3. Characters
The character of Shrek is so iconic, its practically become a household name. It was brought to life so wonderfully in the first one. Donkey is also a great character, the dynamic they have together is fantastic. It’s also nice to see the Princess Fiona isn’t depicted as a damsel in distress, but a charming and funny character. Lord Farquaad is one of best villains ever put to screen. But as much as I like him, he seems more like a spectacle than a interesting villain. His presence and the way he talks is funny, but deep down he’s just you’re typical bad guy trope. There are a few side characters are not as forgettable like Pinocchio or The Gingerbread Man, but for the most part the rest of them are disposable.
Like I said with the plot, Shrek 2 builds upon it’s already established characters. Shrek deals with some serious personal responsibility, and ponders his significance as an ogre. He and Donkey bring some more comedic moments when they are transformed into a man and horse. The Fairy Godmother is a villain that we understand a little bit better. We watch as she manipulates Harold for her personal gain. Prince Charming is also great as he plays this spoiled lover boy type of character. Then, Puss in Boots. Everything from his cocky demeanor to his adorable big green eyes is loveable. Some way, some how, the moment we see him onscreen we are easily won over by him.
What Shrek 2 does with it’s characters as a whole is much better than the first one. More character depth is given to Shrek and Fiona. What the supporting cast also brings to the table is enough to propel the plot to it’s fullest potential. So Shrek 2 is the winner.
I could list out a few other factors like funny moments or references, but that really varies from person to person. Choosing which Shrek movie I like more is like choosing what parent I like more. But in the end I would have to say that Shrek 2 is better. There are things I like in the first Shrek film that I like more, but as a whole, Shrek 2 is the better film.
If you haven’t seen the first two Shrek films, than you haven’t lived.